It’s been a while since we last reviewed Matty’s Bar and Grill in New Berlin, and after a recent stop, it’s clear why this place continues to rack up accolades. Their website proudly claims Home of Milwaukee’s Best Bloody (2019, 2020, 2021, voted at teh Great Lakes Hemophilia Foundation’s Best Bloody Contest) and the Bloody Mary Festival’s 2022 People’s Choice Award — and honestly, there’s a reason for it.
Matty’s doesn’t just serve a Bloody Mary. They’ve built a reputation around it.
From their website:
We offer 2 different sizes of Bloody Marys:
Pint Size, or as we call it the Baby size (when you see all 3 you would agree the name suits it.)
The Matty Mary which is for the Bloody lover; this biggin is 25 oz. and is garnished with the following:
Celery, Cucumber, Kosher Dill Pickle, Pepperoncini, Olive, Sausage Beef Stick, and a Mozzarella Cheese Whip…..and of course served with a chaser of your liking.
The Ultimate Matty Mary This beauty is the same whopping 25 oz. as our Matty Mary, with all the same delicious Fixin’s. What makes this one really special is the topping that is added to this already monstrous concoction! It rotates weekly and is always a crowd-pleaser. Past toppings have included: a Mini Brat, a Tamale, Bourbon Glazed Meatballs……the list just goes on and on!
Spread the word, your Bloody Mary destination has just been found!
The last time I was here, I was also amazed to learn that they have their Bloody Marys on tap. In a state where consistency and efficiency matter (especially during busy brunch hours), having it on tap is a power move.
This one deserved a more thorough spotlight than we gave it before.
The Bloody Mary
• Spices/Flavor: Smooth, refreshing, balanced — award-winning for a reason
• Fixin’s: See above.
• Chaser: See above.
• Presentation: On tap; available in pint or giant size
• Price: Unsure
If you’re keeping a Milwaukee-area Bloody bucket list, Matty’s isn’t just a stop — it’s a staple.
Out For Bloodies 