After a great morning paddleboarding on Pewaukee Lake, 4 Keeps, Pewaukee’s self-proclaimed “neighborhood dive bar,” was the perfect stop to relax and enjoy a cold beverage.
Their Bloody Mary may not be over-the-top with garnishes, but the flavor more than makes up for it. It was one of those Bloodies that immediately makes you take another sip. Well-seasoned, balanced, and just plain delicious. At only $7, it’s also one of the better values you’ll find.
The garnish included a pickle, two olives, cheese, and a beef stick, plus a shorty beer chaser—a classic Wisconsin finishing touch.
The Bloody Mary
• Spices/Flavor: Excellent flavor with a well-balanced mix
• Fixin’s: Pickle, two olives, cheese, beef stick
• Chaser: Shorty beer
• Presentation: Classic Wisconsin-style with traditional garnishes
• Price: $7
Whether you’re coming off the lake or just looking for a neighborhood spot with a great Bloody Mary, Four Keeps delivers. Great flavor, a fair price, and a beer chaser make this one an easy recommendation.
Out For Bloodies 