Dousman, WI: Kettle Moraine Golf Club

Posted: May 5, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , , ,
0

Like airports, golf courses are places were a good Bloody Mary just hits different. And this one at Kettle Moraine Golf Club was especially tasty.

We’ve reviewed their bloody before, but it’s been quite awhile. I had this one during the Icebreaker Scramble, their opening tournament of the season. We were on a bit of a frost delay (very on-brand for early-season Wisconsin golf), so it felt like the perfect time to grab a Bloody—especially with it being The Masters Tournament weekend.

This one came in a to-go styrofoam cup, which isn’t ideal from a presentation standpoint—but also completely understandable given the setting. Golf course, tournament day, trying to keep things moving… it gets a pass.

The garnish was simple and solid: a beef stick, a pickle, and two olives. Nothing excessive, but exactly what you want when you’re heading out to the course. They also asked if I wanted it spicy (always appreciate the option), and the spicy version delivered—really flavorful with a nice kick.

No chaser on this one, and I didn’t catch the price, but overall, it was a really enjoyable Bloody—especially in the moment.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Spicy with a nice kick, really enjoyable
• Fixin’s: Beef stick, pickle, two olives
• Chaser: None
• Presentation: Served in a to-go styrofoam cup (golf course practical)
• Price: Not listed

If you’re kicking off the golf season at Kettle Moraine, this is a great way to start your round. It’s not about over-the-top presentation—it’s about a solid, spicy Bloody that fits the moment perfectly.

Muskego, WI: The Local

Posted: May 5, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , ,
0

The Local is one of those neighborhood spots that people just know has a Bloody Mary—even if it’s not actually listed on the cocktail menu. And in this case, that assumption pays off.

Their Bloody comes in a full pint glass and includes a beer chaser of your choice, which is always a strong start. It’s garnished with all the essentials: a lemon-lime wedge, pickle, olive, cheese, and a beef stick—nothing over-the-top, but everything you want in a classic Wisconsin Bloody.

Interestingly, it’s not featured on their cocktail list, despite the rest of their drinks sitting around the $8 mark. So while I didn’t get an official price or confirmation on the mix or vodka used, it’s fair to assume this one falls right in line with the rest of their menu.

Flavor-wise, this is a straightforward, easy-drinking Bloody. It doesn’t try to do anything flashy, but it delivers a solid, familiar profile that works well whether you’re there for brunch or just stopping in.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Classic and approachable, easy to sip
• Fixin’s: Lemon-lime, pickle, olive, cheese, beef stick
• Chaser: Beer of your choice
• Presentation: Full pint glass with traditional garnishes
• Price: Estimated $8

If you’re at The Local, don’t overthink it—just order the Bloody. Even without a formal menu listing, it holds its own as a reliable, no-frills option that gets the job done.

Hartford, WI: The Mineshaft

Posted: May 5, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , ,
0

The Mineshaft is one of those places that feels like it should already be on the Bloody Mary review list—and somehow slipped through the cracks. But it absolutely deserves a spot.

Their Bloody Mary comes in a mason jar mug with a handle, which immediately gives it that fun, casual Wisconsin charm. It’s finished with a seasoned rim (always a win), and topped with a classic skewer: cheese, pickle, beef stick, and olive. Simple, but it hits all the right notes.

According to their menu, the Bloody is made with two shots of Smirnoff triple distilled vodka and their “world’s best Bloody Mary mix.” While I didn’t confirm the exact mix during my visit, the flavor backs up the claim—it’s bold, well-seasoned, and leans into that traditional, savory profile that Bloody fans are looking for.

And for $7 (per their website), it’s a great value—especially considering it also comes with a beer chaser of your choice.

This is one of those Bloodies that doesn’t try to reinvent anything—it just executes the classic formula really well. Between the strong pour, solid garnish game, and approachable price point, it’s an easy one to recommend.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Bold, classic, and savory with a well-seasoned mix
• Fixin’s: Cheese, pickle, beef stick, olive (plus listed celery & lemon)
• Chaser: Beer of your choice
• Presentation: Mason jar mug with handle and a seasoned rim
• Price: $7 (per website)

If you find yourself in Hartford, The Mineshaft is a must-stop for not only bloodies, but just in general. It’s a staple of Washington County. The restaurant is huge and it’s menu is just as big. There’s something for everyone, plus its relatively affordable.

West Allis, WI: 4th Base

Posted: May 5, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , , , ,
0

4th Base Restaurant is one of those classic spots that has built a loyal following over the years—especially for its sports bar/ old-school supper club feel and over-the-top presentations. We’ve talked about it before, and while there’s a lot to love, the experience can be a bit of a mixed bag.

I hadn’t been here in years, but there was a special 90s theme brunch going on that happened to coincide with my birthday, so I decided to check it out with a group of friends.

The Bloody itself leans into presentation. It’s topped with a skewer of veggies (pickle, carrot, cheese and broccoli) and extras, including haystack onion rings. It definitely gives you that classic Wisconsin-style, “drink plus snack” experience. And, it also comes with a full pint beer chaser—a major win. You can choose any beer, and I went with a Blue Moon, which felt like a slightly unexpected pairing but still did the job.

Flavor-wise, it’s solid and drinkable, though this one is more about the overall experience than a standout mix. The real draw is everything that comes with it—the chaser, the garnishes, and the setting.

One thing that continues to stand out (and not necessarily in a good way) is the lack of a clear menu. 4th Base is known for its “we’ll make you whatever you want” approach, which some people love—but if you’re someone who prefers structure or likes to know pricing upfront, it can feel a little overwhelming. I guess that’s what deters me from going there more frequently.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Classic and easy-drinking, but not overly memorable
• Fixin’s: Haystack onion rings, pickle, carrot, cheese, broccoli
• Chaser: Full pint beer (choose your own—I went with Blue Moon)
• Presentation: Over-the-top Wisconsin-style with a loaded skewer
• Price: Not listed

If you’re heading to Fourth Base, go in ready for a unique, anything-goes dining experience. The Bloody Mary is fun, filling, and comes with a great chaser—but the overall visit might depend on how much you enjoy a little unpredictability with your order.

Wauwatosa, WI: Explorium Brew Pub

Posted: March 15, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , , ,
0

Explorium Brewpub in Wauwatosa is one of those places that quietly does a lot of things really well. Known for their wide selection of craft beers and an expansive menu, it’s a great spot to meet friends, grab a bite, and—of course—order a Bloody Mary.

I went with their regular Bloody, though they also offer a spicy/pepper vodka option for those who like a little extra kick. This one came nicely garnished with a pickle, olive, a small piece of string cheese, and a mini beef stick. Even better, it’s served with a chaser of your choice from their extensive beer list—and Explorium has a lot of beers to choose from.

The flavor was really solid—well-balanced and easy to drink, making it one of the better Bloodies I’ve had recently. It’s the kind of Bloody Mary that hits the spot whether you’re starting a weekend brunch or just stopping in for a casual drink.

One thing that always surprises me is that Explorium never seems overly packed when I visit and its predecessors, ABV Social and Good City, were also never very full. However, with the quality of the food, the variety of beers, and a strong Bloody Mary to match, it’s actually a fantastic meeting spot right in the heart of the Mayfair Collection.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Well-balanced and flavorful
• Fixin’s: Pickle, olive, string cheese, beef stick
• Chaser: Your choice of from their extensive beer list
• Presentation: Classic Bloody presentation with traditional garnishes
• Price: $8 per website

If you’re in Wauwatosa and looking for a great place to meet up with friends, Explorium Brewpub deserves a spot on your list. The Bloody Mary alone is worth ordering—and with all those beers on tap, you won’t leave thirsty.

Note: Explorium has two additional locations, including Greendale and the Third Ward.

Brookfield, WI: Schmidtys Bar & Grill

Posted: March 15, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , ,
0

Schmidtys Off the Rail in Brookfield is one of the newer spots in town, having opened in 2024. The place has clearly been refreshed a bit, and from the looks of it, they’re aiming to be a lively neighborhood hangout with live music, specials, and plenty of events on the calendar.

Naturally, I had to check out the Bloody Mary. Served in a standard pint glass, this one kept things simple. There was no rim seasoning, but it did come with a few classic fixin’s: a beef stick, a chunk of cheese, and an olive. You can also choose any chaser you’d like, which is always a nice touch and a very Wisconsin move.

The Bloody itself was pretty average—nothing particularly bold or memorable, but perfectly drinkable. Sometimes that’s all you need, especially when you’re settling in at a big bar with a lot going on around you.

Schmitty’s looks like it has the potential to be a fun gathering spot, especially when the live music and events are in full swing. If I’m back in the area, I’d definitely pop in again to see what’s happening.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: They used Jimmy Luv’s mix and doctored it up a bit
• Fixin’s: Beef stick, cheese, olive
• Chaser: Your choice
• Presentation: Served in a pint glass, no rim
• Price: Unknown, probably about $10 or

If you’re in the Brookfield/Menomonee Falls area and looking for a lively bar with music and events, Schmidtys Off the Rail could be worth a stop. The Bloody Mary may not steal the spotlight, but it’s a solid companion for a casual afternoon.

Oconomowoc, WI: The Etcetera Bar & Grill

Posted: March 2, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , ,
0

Next up: Etcetera in Oconomowoc — the spot that took over the former Lakerz location.

Right out front, the sign boldly claims “Voted Best Bloody Mary in Oconomowoc,” so naturally, expectations were set.

The Bloody arrived in a little mason jar (always a solid Wisconsin touch) and was garnished with a beef stick, a chunk of cream cheese, a pickle spear, and a pepperoncini. It also came with a chaser — your choice of any of their beers on tap — which is always a win in my book.

Flavor-wise, it was good. Solid. Well-balanced. It had enough spice and body to keep it interesting without overpowering the palate. The garnishes felt classic and satisfying — nothing over-the-top, but no complaints either.

One interesting note: I didn’t see it listed on the drink menu or the food menu, which felt a little odd for something advertised as the “best.” I’m not sure on the price point or the exact mix details, but from a taste standpoint, it delivered.

That said… while it was absolutely enjoyable, I wouldn’t say it stood head and shoulders above some of the other Bloody Marys I’ve had recently. It’s a good, dependable Bloody — especially with that beer chaser — but not necessarily one that redefines the category.

If you’re in Oconomowoc and craving a classic Wisconsin-style Bloody with solid flavor and the full chaser experience, it’s worth a stop.

Menonomee Falls, WI: Social Haus

Posted: March 2, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , ,
0

The Spicy Bloody Mary at Social Haus in Menomonee Falls keeps things fairly traditional but brings enough heat to make it interesting. Made with Absolut Peppar vodka, their had a noticeable peppery kick without overwhelming the drink.

The garnish lineup is straightforward — pickle, olive, lemon, and lime — but well executed. And the generous beer chaser adds value, especially in a state where that’s practically expected.

It’s not overly elaborate, but it’s dependable and drinkable — a solid choice if you’re already there for brunch or drinks.

We were also impressed with the variety on their breakfast menu… and the fact that you can get free pancakes with the purchase of a beverage!

Spicy Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Peppery heat, balanced, drinkable
• Fixin’s: Pickle, olive, lemon, lime
• Chaser: Generous beer chaser
• Presentation: Classic, no-frills
• Price: Unsure,

The verdict? Fun place. We will be back!

Wauwatosa, WI: Buckatabon

Posted: March 2, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , ,
0

Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club (from the Lowlands Group, which has built a reputation for strong Bloody Marys across all of its restaurants, including Cafe Benelux and Cafe Hollander) appears to have upped its bloody mary game since we last reviewed this spot in 2022, so we’re re-reviewing!

Once again, I tried the Buckatabon Bloody, their classic house version. Made with vodka, Bloody Mary mix, celery juice, and topped with Frank’s Secret Shake seasoning, it had a fresh, savory flavor profile with a little extra kick from the seasoning blend. The garnish lineup was simple but thoughtful, and the small beer chaser sealed the deal — especially at a very reasonable price point.

You’ll see they now offer several new bloodies including “That Dills My Pickle,” “The Smug Clam,” the “Spicy Badger,” and even a non-alcoholic “Side Salad” version — which shows just how seriously they take their Bloody menu.

The supper club vibes and strong brunch menu make this another solid stop from the Lowlands Group family.

New Berlin, WI: Matty’s Bar & Grille

Posted: February 18, 2026 in Uncategorized
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
0

It’s been a while since we last reviewed Matty’s Bar and Grill in New Berlin, and after a recent stop, it’s clear why this place continues to rack up accolades. Their website proudly claims Home of Milwaukee’s Best Bloody (2019, 2020, 2021, voted at teh Great Lakes Hemophilia Foundation’s Best Bloody Contest) and the Bloody Mary Festival’s 2022 People’s Choice Award — and honestly, there’s a reason for it.

Matty’s doesn’t just serve a Bloody Mary. They’ve built a reputation around it.

From their website:

We offer 2 different sizes of Bloody Marys:

Pint Size, or as we call it the Baby size (when you see all 3 you would agree the name suits it.)

The Matty Mary which is for the Bloody lover; this biggin is 25 oz. and is garnished with the following:

Celery, Cucumber, Kosher Dill Pickle, Pepperoncini, Olive, Sausage Beef Stick, and a Mozzarella Cheese Whip…..and of course served with a chaser of your liking.

The Ultimate Matty Mary  This beauty is the same whopping 25 oz. as our Matty Mary, with all the same delicious Fixin’s. What makes this one really special is the topping that is added to this already monstrous concoction!  It rotates weekly and is always a crowd-pleaser.  Past toppings have included: a Mini Brat, a Tamale, Bourbon Glazed Meatballs……the list just goes on and on!

Spread the word, your Bloody Mary destination has just been found!

The last time I was here, I was also amazed to learn that they have their Bloody Marys on tap. In a state where consistency and efficiency matter (especially during busy brunch hours), having it on tap is a power move.

This one deserved a more thorough spotlight than we gave it before.

The Bloody Mary

• Spices/Flavor: Smooth, refreshing, balanced — award-winning for a reason
• Fixin’s: See above.
• Chaser: See above.
• Presentation: On tap; available in pint or giant size
• Price: Unsure

If you’re keeping a Milwaukee-area Bloody bucket list, Matty’s isn’t just a stop — it’s a staple.

Older Entries
Newer Entries